Another lot from Spain that I'm needing help with.
These first two are the same butterfly. Despite the evident lack of a tail I think this might be a Provencal Short-tailed blue:
1:
2:
Again, the nect two are the same butterfly, Escher's Blue??
3:
4:
No underside to this one I'm afraid:
5:
Another Provencal Short-tailed Blue?
6:
This pair are the same butterfly:
7:
8:
Thanks,
Robin
Spanish Blues Part 1(sounds like a song)
- Padfield
- Administrator
- Posts: 8375
- Joined: Sun Nov 05, 2006 10:19 pm
- Location: Leysin, Switzerland
- Contact:
Re: Spanish Blues Part 1(sounds like a song)
I'm stuck at school for an hour waiting for a class, so I'll have a go at these. I can't check on the distributions from here, though.
1 & 2 - I'd go for female osiris. There's no hint of even a kink in the margin to suggest alcetas, and female osiris often has that marginal spot.
3 & 4 - I think you're right. Chapman's (thersites) is very similar but usually shows less half-chequering and rather a greyish half fringe on the hindwing.
5 - female of thersites, icarus or escheri. I would go for escheri, just because it looks very like a picture I have of female escheri.
6 - I incline towards osiris again.
7 & 8 - escheri
Guy
EDIT: Still at school, with a chance to review these again. I'm really not sure about 1, 2 and 6. The other option for 1 & 2, of minimus, can't be ruled out. I was influenced by 6. And 6 could be alcetas! Male alcetas sometimes has virtually no tail at all, as in this picture:

So, an alternative for 1, 2 and 6 would be minimus, minimus, alcetas, though the colour of the male alcetas would be anomalous if that were right. Maybe someone else will have a view. I still prefer osiris for all three.
1 & 2 - I'd go for female osiris. There's no hint of even a kink in the margin to suggest alcetas, and female osiris often has that marginal spot.
3 & 4 - I think you're right. Chapman's (thersites) is very similar but usually shows less half-chequering and rather a greyish half fringe on the hindwing.
5 - female of thersites, icarus or escheri. I would go for escheri, just because it looks very like a picture I have of female escheri.
6 - I incline towards osiris again.
7 & 8 - escheri
Guy
EDIT: Still at school, with a chance to review these again. I'm really not sure about 1, 2 and 6. The other option for 1 & 2, of minimus, can't be ruled out. I was influenced by 6. And 6 could be alcetas! Male alcetas sometimes has virtually no tail at all, as in this picture:

So, an alternative for 1, 2 and 6 would be minimus, minimus, alcetas, though the colour of the male alcetas would be anomalous if that were right. Maybe someone else will have a view. I still prefer osiris for all three.
Guy's Butterflies: https://www.guypadfield.com
The Butterflies of Villars-Gryon : https://www.guypadfield.com/villarsgryonbook.html
The Butterflies of Villars-Gryon : https://www.guypadfield.com/villarsgryonbook.html
Re: Spanish Blues Part 1(sounds like a song)
Guy - thanks for your help, much appreciated.
Robin
Robin