Small Tortoiseshell (Early Stages)

[Vince Massimo]

Part 1 – The Small Tortoiseshell - Eggs and Larvae

The Small Tortoiseshell seemed to have been ever-present in our childhoods but, since then, numbers have been fluctuating for various reasons. However, there has been a noticeable recovery in the past few years, with 2013 being a very good season.

This species is double-brooded (except in Scotland) and adults hibernate through the winter, emerging in early March, after which they mate. The principal larval host plants are Common Nettle (Urtica dioica) and Small Nettle (Urtica urens), with those growing in full sun being favoured. Eggs are laid in batches of 50-100 on the underside of a young leaf, usually towards the top of the plant. The females are very particular as to where they lay and it is not uncommon to find two individuals ovipositing on the same leaf, or multiple egg batches. Sometimes the are also seen laying with Peacocks. The best times for finding egg-laying females seems to be between midday and 2pm and those that I observed were engaged for between 20 minutes and 1 hour depending on the size of the batch.

Small Tortoiseshell ovipositing - Coulsdon, Surrey 14-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell ovipositing - Coulsdon, Surrey 9-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell ovipositing - Coulsdon, Surrey 14-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell, fresh multiple egg batches - Coulsdon, Surrey 14-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell and Peacock egg-laying - North Stoke, Sussex 11-Apr-2017

Small Tortoiseshell (R) and Peacock (L) eggs - North Stoke, Sussex 11-Apr-2017

Small Tortoiseshell eggs - Crawley, Sussex 30-Mar-2017

The eggs hatch in approximately 14 days and the young larvae spin a dense web of silk around the nearest leaf to form a protective tent where they feed, rest and moult communally, though often emerging in sunny conditions.

Small Tortoiseshell eggs hatching - Coulsdon, Surrey 16-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell, 1-day old 1st instar larvae - Caterham, Surrey 20-May-2013

Small Tortoiseshell, 3-day old 1st instar larvae - Caterham, Surrey 22-May-2013

Small Tortoiseshell, 8-day old 1st instar larvae - Caterham, Surrey 27-May-2013

Small Tortoiseshell 2nd instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 25-Apr-2017

Small Tortoiseshell, 18-day old 2nd instar larvae - Caterham, Surrey 6-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell 2nd instar larva (pre-moult) - Crawley, Sussex 26-June-2020

The early instar larvae of Small Tortoiseshell are very similar in appearance and behaviour to those of the Peacock at this stage, but towards the end of their 2nd instar they have a yellow and black chequered appearance which is quite diagnostic of the species. Then, when they emerge from their second moult, (into their 3rd instar) they start to show characteristic yellow striping along their backs and flanks. However, at this stage their colouration can be extremely variable, ranging from mainly yellow to almost completely black.

Small Tortoiseshell larva (early 3rd instar) - Crawley, Sussex 8-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 3rd instar larvae (dark form) - Coulsdon, Surrey 31-May-2013

Small Tortoiseshell 3rd instar larvae (dark form) - Coulsdon, Surrey 31-May-2013

Small Tortoiseshell 3rd instar larvae (pale form) - Coulsdon, Surrey 4-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell 3rd instar larvae (pale form) - Crawley, Sussex 26-June-2020

Small Tortoiseshell 3rd instar larvae - Coulsdon, Surrey 31-May-2012

Small Tortoiseshell larva (3rd instar pre-moult) - Crawley, Sussex 25-Apr-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 4th instar larvae (pale form) - Crawley, Sussex 30-Apr-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 4th instar larvae (dark form) - Crawley, Sussex 5-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 4th instar larvae - Crawley, Sussex 5-June-2016

Small Tortoiseshell 4th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 7-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 4th instar larva - Caterham, Surrey 6-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell 4th instar larvae - Caterham, Surrey 5-June-2013

Initially, the larvae stay together, moving across the plant or on to new plants in search of fresh terminal leaves, forming webs as they go, but after the third moult (which results in the 4th instar), the larvae start to disperse.

After separating into smaller groups the larvae dispense with a protective web and form shelters from nettle leaves and a few strands of silk. An individual leaf is utilised and is either roughly folded downwards (umbrella-style) or carefully folded upwards to form a more symmetrical structure (purse-style). The downward-facing structure was found to be used by individuals and small groups, while the upward-facing folded leaf was the type most commonly encountered in the wild and usually accommodated only one larva The principal function of these structures is to act as a shelter for larvae while they rest or moult. Whilst these may look very similar to shelters created by Red Admiral larvae, they are notable in that they tended to be clustered in a small area, usually close to the old larval web. The larvae were observed to feed at the tips of both types of these shelters for a short while before moving on.

Small Tortoiseshell larval shelters - Caterham, Surrey 8-June-2012

Small Tortoiseshell larval shelter - Caterham, Surrey 6-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell laval moulting shelters - Coulsdon, Surrey 9-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell larval shelters - Crawley, Sussex 5-June-2016

Whilst larvae usually moult in a sheltered area, one of those being reared moulted out in the open. This is a very vulnerable stage in the development of the larva, and they have to remain inactive for over a day while changes take place inside the old skin. Nearing the time of the moult, the old head capsule (which now looks too small for the body) becomes just an empty shell and the new paler head can be seen being formed just behind it.

Small Tortoiseshell larva (4th instar pre-moult) - Caterham, Surrey 8-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell larva (5th instar post moult) - Caterham, Surrey 9-June-2013

After moulting the new larval skin quickly dries and the head capsule darkens.

Small Tortoiseshell larva (4th instar pre-moult) - Caterham, Surrey 8-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell larva (5th instar post moult) - Caterham, Surrey 9-June-2013

At this stage of their development they now feed in the open and can often be found basking on leaves in a characteristic curled position.

Small Tortoiseshell 4th instar larva basking - Coulsdon, Surrey 9-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell 5th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 24-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 5th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 9-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 5th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 9-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 5th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 3-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 5th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 6-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 5th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 15-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 5th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 9-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 5th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 6-May-2017

Small Tortoiseshell 5th instar larva - Crawley, Sussex 7-May-2017

There are four moults in all and when fully grown the larva will reach a length of approximately 30mm. They then usually leave the plant and seek a pupation site typically in dense vegetation or on fences and walls. They suspend themselves from a pad of silk in the standard “J” position for approximately 24 hours before pupation takes place.

Small Tortoiseshell larva suspended for pupation - Caterham, Surrey 12-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell larva preparing to pupate - Caterham, Surrey 12-June-2013

Pupation itself takes approximately 4 minutes to complete, commencing with the larva elongating and pulsing.

Small Tortoiseshell larva commencing pupation - Caterham, Surrey 13-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell larva commencing pupation - Caterham, Surrey 13-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell larva pupating - Caterham, Surrey 13-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell larva pupating - Caterham, Surrey 13-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell larva pupating - Caterham, Surrey 13-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell larva completing pupation - Caterham, Surrey 13-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell (fresh pupa) - Caterham, Surrey 13-June-2013

End of part One

[Vince Massimo]

Part Two - The Small Tortoiseshell - Pupa

A few hours after pupation the pupa hardens and takes up its final colouration.

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (freshly emerged) - Caterham, Surrey 13-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (1 hour old) - Caterham, Surrey 13-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (3 days old) - Caterham, Surrey 16-June-2013

The pupa is very similar in appearance to that of the Peacock, (see: viewtopic.php?f=37&t=6485 ) but is slightly smaller and slimmer with blunter dorsal spines. Of the two species, that of the Small Tortoiseshell is the one most likely to be encountered in the wild, although I never have, despite monitoring many larval webs and over a thousand larvae in the past year.

Small Tortoiseshell pupa - Caterham, Surrey 16-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell pupa - Caterham, Surrey 16-June-2013

The colouration is variable, depending on the pupation site. The intermediate form is shown above, but there is also a dark form.

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (dark form) - Caterham, Surrey 22-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (dark form) - Caterham, Surrey 22-June-2013

However, the most common is the beautiful golden form.

Small Tortoiseshell pupa - Caterham, Surrey 22-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell pupa - Caterham, Surrey 22-June-2013

Small Tortoiseshell pupa - Caterham, Surrey 22-June-2013

This then develops a coppery/green metallic sheen in the day leading towards emergence.

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (27 hours before emergence) - Caterham, Surrey 2-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (21 hours before emergence) - Caterham, Surrey 2-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (20 hours before emergence) - Caterham, Surrey 2-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (19 hours before emergence) - Caterham, Surrey 2-July-2013

The emergence process itself takes approximately 60-90 seconds.

Small Tortoiseshell pupa (2 hours before emergence) - Caterham, Surrey 3-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell starting to emerge - Caterham, Surrey 3-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell emerging - Caterham, Surrey 3-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell emerging - Caterham, Surrey 3-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell emerging - Caterham, Surrey 3-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell emerging - Caterham, Surrey 3-July-2013

Small Tortoiseshell drying wings - Caterham, Surrey 3-July-2013

All adults were released as soon as they were ready to fly, but only one stayed around long enough to be photographed. This turned out to be a very dark individual.

Small Tortoiseshell (dark form) upon release - Caterham, Surrey 3-July-2013

End of part two.

[Vince Massimo]

Part Three - background and other observations

This report is the result of work carried out during the 2012 and 2013 seasons, with many images being taken in the wild. A batch of 5 third-instar larvae was collected in 2012, but they all died in mysterious circumstances. In 2013 a number of larvae, ranging through 3rd, 4th and 5th instars were collected as well as a small batch of newly laid eggs. These were all reared on potted nettle plants which were kept in an airy outbuilding. Only 5 of the larvae that hatched from eggs were retained (the rest being released). These acted as a “control batch” and none were found to be affected by disease or parasites. Of the 24 larvae taken from the wild, 9 perished, mainly due to parasitism. This equated to a 37% loss rate of wild larvae.

The parasites were all found to be Tachinid flies. Seven parasitic grubs emerged from the butterfly larvae and pupated. However they never hatched and the pupae remain unidentified

Puparium of parasitic Tachinid fly - Caterham, Surrey 18-June-2013

Puparium of parasitic Tachinid fly - Caterham, Surrey 18-June-2013

Another grub emerged, but this time from a discoloured butterfly chrysalis and this eventually emerged as an adult fly which appears to be either Phryxe vulgaris or Phryxe nemea.

Small Tortoiseshell (parasitised pupa) - Caterham, Surrey 27-June-2013

Puparium of Phryxe vulgaris or Phryxe nemea - Caterham, Surrey 27-June-2013

Phryxe vulgaris or Phryxe nemea - Caterham, Surrey 8-July-2013

Phryxe vulgaris or Phryxe nemea - Caterham, Surrey 8-July-2013

As the Small Tortoiseshell larvae and pupae were all reared inside a building, their development rates may have been affected compared to those in the wild, so the following summary can only be considered as a guide.

02-May-2013 eggs laid.
19-May-2013 eggs hatched (after 17 days)
26-June-2013 larvae pupated (at 38 days old)
08-July-2013 adults emerged (after 12 days)

Thanks go to Chris Raper for advice regarding the Tachinid flies.


Reading References:

The Butterflies of Britain and Ireland (Thomas and Lewington 2014)
UK Butterflies Website

Vince

[Pete Eeles]

Not sure what to say Vince - a top notch report, superb photos and, most importantly, interesting! Definitely the best to date

Cheers,

- Pete

[Padfield]

Seconded! Fantastic work.

Guy

[Mark Colvin]

Great work, Vince.

Super attention to detail and absolutely fascinating ...

[Neil Hulme]

Fantastic reports Vince. The shots showing that bizarre green and metallic colouration of the pre-hardened pupae are brilliant.
BWs, Neil

[ChrisC]

well.... I thought it was ok superb stuff Vince, you have raised your own standard to live up to now though.

Chris

[David M]

That's the most astonishing sequence I've ever seen on this site.

Vince, if I were Prime Minister, you'd soon be Lord Massimo (has a nice 'ring' to it, doesn't it?)

[Vince Massimo]

Many thanks for the enthusiastic reception guys. I'll forgo the peerage for the moment .
I just hope that the report helps to generate a wider level of interest and that F.W. Frohawk is looking down on us all and nodding approvingly.

Vince

[David M]

....and that F.W. Frohawk is looking down on us all and nodding approvingly.

He'll probably be thinking "S**t, I wish we'd had digital photography!